by Peel Fan Thu Mar 25, 2010 10:16 pm
Steve Nash, your post is written like someone who is selectively trying to prove a point while ignoring the obvious.
How is it that Peel has so much talent and yet no team can advance beyond the quarter-finals over the past decade or so?
I think the recent game vs. Durham and the fact that Peel has lost more players to the US in the past couple of years than any other region both speak for themselves. The region doesn't lack for talent.
So why the lack of final four berths?
I think it's pretty obvious that Peel, unlike the other regions, doesn't see its talent concentrated only a small number of schools. Let's face it, when some of the other regions have open borders (Toronto Public and Toronto Catholic), the best players are going to, quite rightly, go to the top programs. No rules are being broken and everything is above board but the fact is that this means that it is easier to create a powerhouse.
In other regions, despite more standardized boundaries, you still see many of the top players end up at only a small number of programs. For the longest time, there was really only one program that was going to win it all in Durham though now that has at lest expanded to two or three. In York, one team seems to routinely draw the best players at both the junior and senior level. Halton, is a whole other world, where questionable transfers seem to be approved all the time.
Peel seems to be the only region where the concentration of talent doesn't seem to take place at anything close to the level of the other regions. Whether this is simply due to less pressure to recruit, a larger number of programs that are attractive to players, or stricter transfer enforcement is up in the air. I will mention that Peel is the only region that has a rule that restricts grade 9s from outside a school's boundaries from playing sports in their first year unless they are part of a regional program. (e.g. AP, extended French, etc...and unlike Halton the high skills specialist majors are not included, and taken advantage of) They also have a regional administrator who is renowned throughout the province for being a stickler for the rules and very good at catching almost every irrgularity in transfer requests.
What this all means is that the talent in Peel is spread much thinner than most regions. Do some players manage to cross boundaries: sure, it's impossible to stop 100%. However, is it possible to build a basketball factory in Peel using players from throughout the wider region: no way. That, more than anything, is the reason Peel can't seem to break into the final four at OFSAA these days. It's a credit to programs lie D'Youville, Campion, Goetz, Loyola, and Ascension over the past few years that they have still managed to be competitive with the top GTA programs despite this.