by lovethegame Tue Nov 15, 2011 10:38 am
@HamiltonBall: Agreed on some points, others you go way too far.
The only person diminishing what Holy Trinity accomplished at Pinky is NBA Lockout/Loyola guy. He casually overlooked that 1 point overtime battle that Trinity gave Martins, yet uses Martins as a springboard for his theory that Loyola had a harder time of it. Right.
As for Loyola, noone is saying their win over Eastern is a fluke. But a Loyola / Eastern match in Hamilton at McMaster no less is not neutral ground. Let's not fool ourselves here. Good for Loyola, they beat Eastern in a highly Loyola friendly environment after a pretty easy pool...let's seem them repeat in a Peel or Toronto gym in a higher level tournament overall, is all.
Notre Dame will prove themselves to be far better than they are ranked right now.
As for Cathedral, St Thomas More, McNab: they did not participate in the biggest tournament of the year in their own city, for whatever reason. When/if they venture into the GTA this year, they will have their chance to prove their worth. No sense boosting them until they show up and play some teams.
As for Toronto vs Outside Toronto talent in general: something to the order of 75% of the best players in each respective class (2012, 2013, 2014) from Toronto are no longer with us because they are playing in the USA, in what some call record numbers. A much higher proportion of elite Toronto players left to go south to prep than did elite outside Toronto players. The Toronto pool as a result is thinner, and it wouldn't be at all surprising to see further out teams do better this year. Having said all that, and while they could well go far this year, it's scary to see what appears to be a much improved over the summer team like Holy Trinity could do if a guy like Anthony Pate had stuck around. Serious OFSAA contender with maybe the lack of a high level big being the only thing holding them back. Same argument for other Toronto/near border teams as well...you apply that logic also to the other teams ie if Andrews Wiggins had stuck around, if Jayln Pennie had stuck around, Isaiah Watkins, Damion Rashford, etc etc, and we're right back at square 1 again with core of Toronto and very near outlying schools like Trinity to the west and Pickering to the east and Vaughan to the north competing solidly at the top of Ontario. Hamilton didn't lose a heck of alot of players to prep, and yet still the best of Hamilton couldn't make it out of their region to OFSAA last year. Umm...